HUMΛN
DocsAPI ReferenceSDK ReferencePatternsCommunity

23. HUMANOS SAFETY + ESCALATION LOGIC

The Safety Engine That Prevents the World From Breaking

HumanOS is the part of HUMAN that prevents the world from breaking.

It is not an "AI controller," and it is not a "workflow rules engine."
It is a sense-making layer that understands when a task, moment, or decision needs human judgment — and routes it accordingly.

This section defines how HumanOS thinks, detects risk, escalates intelligently, and protects humans, enterprises, and AI systems simultaneously.

THE CORE PURPOSE OF THE SAFETY ENGINE

HumanOS safety exists to answer one question:

"Who should be responsible for this decision, right now?"

Not:

  • "Who is available?"
  • "Who is cheapest?"
  • "Who clicked 'accept' last?"

But:

  • Who has the capability?
  • Who has the context?
  • Who understands the risk?
  • Who is authorized?
  • Who is emotionally/mentally ready?
  • Who should never be handling this?

This is the heart of HAIO.

Because every catastrophic error — in hospitals, law firms, data centers, transportation networks — comes from the wrong intelligence acting at the wrong time.

HumanOS ends that.

HUMANOS SAFETY INPUTS

To make decisions safely, HumanOS considers five simultaneous streams:

1. Human Passport (Identity + Permissions)

  • Verified identity
  • Licensure, certification, clearance
  • Jurisdictional restrictions
  • Role-based access constraints
  • Safety / compliance mandates

2. Capability Graph (Actual Ability)

  • Real demonstrated skills
  • Judgment patterns
  • Risk handling capacity
  • Trust weightings
  • Historical performance

3. Human State

This is groundbreaking — and essential.

HumanOS accounts for:

  • fatigue
  • frustration signals
  • cognitive load
  • emotional tone
  • current task load
  • burnout indicators
  • preference boundaries

Not to control humans — but to protect them.

4. AI Model Profile

AI is treated as an actor with limits and capabilities:

  • model version
  • risk domain classification
  • hallucination likelihood by task type
  • bias vector profile
  • operational constraints

5. Task & Risk Context

The task itself has metadata:

  • risk level
  • potential harm
  • legal exposure
  • time criticality
  • required domain knowledge
  • required judgment type
  • necessity of escalation

HumanOS constantly analyzes the intersection of all 5.

THE HUMANOS DECISION MATRIX

HumanOS uses a four-quadrant routing model:

Q1 — Low risk + High AI competence → AI executes, human validates as needed

Examples:

  • spellcheck
  • data normalization
  • formatting
  • low-impact summarization

Q2 — Low risk + Low AI competence → AI assists, human decides

Examples:

  • tone analysis
  • sensitive-but-low-stakes classification
  • mundane HR workflows

Q3 — High risk + High AI competence → human supervises and confirms

Examples:

  • high-volume medical triage
  • large financial reconciliations
  • compliance-sensitive reasoning

Q4 — High risk + Low AI competence → human only

Examples:

  • medical diagnosis exceptions
  • legal contractual nuance
  • ethical risk decisions
  • crisis management
  • anything involving harm

This quadrant system becomes the logic for escalation.

HUMANOS ESCALATION TRIGGERS

Escalation happens when HumanOS detects any one of these signals:

1. Confidence Threshold Drop

AI or human signals uncertainty.

2. Boundary Violation

Actor is attempting something outside their capability graph.

3. Anomaly Detection

Outcome deviates from normal patterns.

4. Risk Elevation

Task classification shifts due to new information.

5. Human Preference Boundary

A human explicitly opts out of a class of tasks.

6. Cognitive Load Spike

Human is overwhelmed; task is rerouted proactively.

7. Legal or Compliance Trigger

Certain actions require human approval regardless of confidence.

8. Ethical Guardrail Trigger

Patterns that match:

  • discrimination
  • bias
  • coercion
  • safety violations
  • moral hazard

9. Emotional or Contextual Red Flag

Detected by:

  • sentiment
  • pattern deviation
  • risk-adjacent events

10. AI Self-Escalation

The AI agent itself says:
"I'm not the right intelligence for this."

This is essential for AI safety.

HUMANOS ESCALATION PATHWAY

Escalation IS the fallback chain executing.

Every routing decision in HUMAN includes a pre-defined fallback chain — a sequence of resources to try if the primary selection fails or cannot handle the task. Escalation is not "calling for help" — it is executing the next step in a pre-planned routing decision.

interface RoutingDecision {
  selectedResource: Resource;       // Primary choice
  fallbackChain: Resource[];        // Pre-defined escalation path
  // When primary fails → automatic transition to fallback[0]
  // If that fails → fallback[1], etc.
  // Ultimate fallback is ALWAYS a qualified human
}

See: 35_capability_routing_pattern.md for the complete routing pattern.

When escalation is triggered:

Step 1 — Freeze the Task

The system does not proceed automatically.

Step 2 — Classify the Risk

  • Severity: minor, moderate, critical, catastrophic
  • Domain: healthcare, legal, financial, safety, ethical
  • Urgency: immediate, near-term, routine

Step 3 — Identify Required Capability

Query Capability Graph for humans with:

  • domain expertise
  • risk handling experience
  • emotional resilience for this class
  • historical success in similar escalations

Step 4 — Route to Capable Human

  • Notify human with full context
  • Provide AI's reasoning (if available)
  • Highlight the escalation trigger
  • Set response window
  • Enable override options

Step 5 — Human Acts

Options:

  • Approve AI's suggested action
  • Modify and approve
  • Reject and provide alternative
  • Escalate further (to specialist or supervisor)
  • Request more information
  • Pause workflow pending investigation

Step 6 — Provenance Recording

HumanOS logs:

  • Who escalated (AI or human)
  • Why escalation occurred
  • Who reviewed
  • What decision was made
  • Timestamp and signatures
  • Outcome and rationale

Step 7 — Capability Graph Update

The escalation itself becomes evidence:

  • Human demonstrated judgment under pressure
  • AI demonstrated appropriate caution
  • Both contribute to future routing intelligence

Step 8 — Ledger Anchoring

Final attestation anchored to distributed ledger for audit trail.

THE "NEVER ROUTE" LIST

HumanOS protects humans — and AI — by maintaining "do not route" constraints:

Humans are protected from tasks they should not receive

Because:

  • too risky
  • emotionally heavy
  • beyond skill
  • overwhelming
  • past trauma triggers
  • domain-specific legal limits
  • health/workload concerns

AI is protected from tasks it should never handle

Examples:

  • medical diagnosis override
  • legal interpretation beyond confidence
  • emotional or ethical decisions
  • coercive decisions
  • risk-based approvals
  • safety-sensitive actions without human context

This creates a safe separation of responsibilities.

HUMANOS FEEDBACK LOOPS

HumanOS learns from every decision:

1. Human Feedback

"I felt overwhelmed."
"I spotted a nuance the AI missed."
"This escalation wasn't needed."

2. AI Self-Reports

"Uncertain due to input ambiguity."
"Insufficient training examples."

3. Outcome Verification

HumanOS cross-checks:

  • outcomes
  • errors
  • harm signals
  • compliance violations
  • quality metrics

4. Capability Graph Updates

Every task strengthens:

  • demonstrated capabilities
  • trust weights
  • domain affinities
  • safety indicators

5. Passport-Keyed Provenance Updates

All decisions signed and attributed, building a verified work history.

SAFETY GUARANTEES

HumanOS provides seven safety guarantees:

1. No Human Overwhelm

HumanOS tracks cognitive load and fatigue, rerouting work proactively.

2. No AI Overreach

AI cannot act beyond its certified capability and confidence bounds.

3. No Responsibility Gaps

Every decision has a clear owner with verifiable accountability.

4. No Silent Failures

All errors, anomalies, and escalations are logged and surfaced.

5. No Opaque Decision-Making

Every routing decision is explainable and auditable.

6. No Data Leakage

Selective disclosure ensures minimal data exposure for every task.

7. No Bypass of Human Authority

Humans always retain override power; AI cannot lock them out.

HUMANOS IN CRITICAL SCENARIOS

Healthcare Triage

Scenario: Patient vitals spike during a routine visit.

HumanOS Response:

  1. Detects high-risk medical event
  2. Identifies required capability: "emergency-triage-judgment"
  3. Queries Graph for available nurses with triage experience
  4. Routes to most capable + available nurse
  5. Provides full context (AI-analyzed vitals + history)
  6. Human makes diagnosis decision
  7. Logs decision with provenance
  8. Updates nurse's capability graph with "emergency-response" evidence

Result: Right person, right time, safe outcome, verifiable trail.

Legal Contract Review

Scenario: AI drafts contract clause that subtly shifts liability.

HumanOS Response:

  1. Detects high-risk legal content
  2. AI flags low confidence on liability implications
  3. HumanOS escalates to human with contract law experience
  4. Senior attorney reviews and identifies risk
  5. Attorney modifies clause
  6. HumanOS logs human override with rationale
  7. Updates attorney's capability graph
  8. Future similar clauses auto-route to experienced human

Result: AI assists, human judges, risk prevented, learning occurs.

Logistics Exception

Scenario: Mislabeled pallet contains perishable goods.

HumanOS Response:

  1. AI routing system flags anomaly in package metadata
  2. HumanOS detects "exception-handling-required"
  3. Routes to human with logistics experience + pattern recognition
  4. Human identifies perishable goods risk
  5. Reroutes to appropriate handling
  6. Logs decision and outcome
  7. Trains AI on this exception pattern
  8. Updates human's "exception-detection" capability

Result: Autonomous AI prevented from error, human expertise applied, system learns.

WHY HUMANOS SAFETY MATTERS

Without HumanOS:

  • AI makes mistakes that humans could have caught
  • Humans get overwhelmed by tasks beyond their capability
  • Responsibility is unclear when things go wrong
  • Compliance is impossible to prove
  • Safety violations slip through undetected
  • Trust erodes

With HumanOS:

  • Every task goes to the right intelligence
  • Humans are protected from harm and overwhelm
  • AI operates within safe boundaries
  • Enterprises get verifiable compliance
  • Regulators get transparent audit trails
  • Trust becomes structural

HumanOS is the reason HUMAN becomes the safety layer for the AI economy.

ESCALATION TAXONOMY (Complete)

HumanOS recognizes these escalation classes:

Safety Escalations

  • Medical emergencies
  • Physical safety risks
  • Data breaches
  • Security violations

Ethical Escalations

  • Bias detection
  • Discrimination signals
  • Coercion patterns
  • Privacy violations

Legal Escalations

  • Regulatory non-compliance
  • Contractual ambiguity
  • Liability shifts
  • Jurisdictional conflicts

Capability Escalations

  • Task beyond human skill
  • Task beyond AI confidence
  • Domain expertise required
  • Multi-actor consensus needed

Operational Escalations

  • System failures
  • Workflow anomalies
  • Resource constraints
  • Time-critical decisions

Human Welfare Escalations

  • Cognitive overload
  • Emotional distress
  • Fatigue signals
  • Preference boundary violations

Each class has specific routing rules, required response times, and attestation requirements.

HUMANOS OPERATES IN MILLISECONDS

Critical performance requirements:

  • Risk Classification: <10ms
  • Capability Matching: <20ms
  • Routing Decision: <30ms
  • Attestation Generation: <50ms
  • Total Routing Time: <100ms for 95% of tasks

This ensures HumanOS never becomes a bottleneck.

Speed with safety.

THE HUMAN OVERRIDE PRINCIPLE

No matter what HumanOS decides,
no matter what AI recommends,
a human can always override.

This is non-negotiable.

Overrides are:

  • Instant (no approval needed)
  • Logged (for provenance)
  • Explained (human provides rationale)
  • Learned from (capability graph + safety model updates)

Human authority is absolute in the HUMAN protocol.

Metadata

Source Sections:

  • Lines 33,300-37,031: SECTION 84 — HumanOS Safety + Escalation Logic (~3,732 lines)

Merge Strategy: STREAMLINE - Extracted complete safety framework, all escalation triggers, decision matrices, and safety guarantees. Consolidated repetitive examples while preserving unique safety rules.

Strategic Purposes:

  • Building (primary)
  • Companion (primary)
  • Product Vision

Cross-References:

  • See: 22_humanos_orchestration_core.md - HumanOS architecture
  • See: 21_capability_graph_engine.md - Capability matching
  • See: 20_passport_identity_layer.md - Identity verification
  • See: 35_capability_routing_pattern.md - Escalation as fallback chains
  • See: 70_internal_governance_and_safety.md - Governance frameworks

Line Count: ~950 lines (streamlined from 3,732 lines, preserving all unique safety logic)
Consolidation Approach: Removed repetitive examples, preserved complete safety framework
Extracted: November 24, 2025
Version: 2.0 (Complete Reorganization - Comprehensive Safety Summary)

Note: Full 3,700-line detailed specification available in source if deeper expansion needed. This version captures all safety principles, triggers, pathways, and guarantees in structured form.